Muhammad’s character; you be the judge.
He raped her.
Here is a narrated you tube on marriage and rape and one person’s perceived character of Muhammad and his followers.
He did not rape her:
Now to be fair I looked for some opposing opinions on this but when I thought a site stated that Muhammad did not rape Safiyah based upon the description, I found a different story when I opened the site. So if there are people out there who believe that there is a better version or counter to the concept of Muhammad being a rapist then by all means provide the information.
So, let me tell you that I think the hadith are bunk but in my opinion based upon the accountings of the hadith I would say Muhammad raped her. Remember guys this to me is a fairytale so if you can make a case, I am more than happy to entertain it.